Home » Living » Best Neighborhoods In Long Island

Best Neighborhoods In Long Island

Best Neighborhoods In Long Island

Long Island, located in the southeastern part of New York State, is known for its beautiful beaches, picturesque scenery, and affluent neighborhoods. With a population of over eight million people, Long Island is home to some of the most desirable neighborhoods in the United States.


Whether you’re a young professional wanting to commute to New York…

…or a family looking for a quiet suburban life, or a retiree seeking a peaceful community, there’s a neighborhood in Long Island that’s perfect for you.

So, let’s explore some of the best Long Island neighborhoods, each with its own unique character, amenities, and attractions.

The Best Neighborhoods In Long Island

Garden City

Garden City

Garden City is a charming village located in Nassau County, Long Island, about 18 miles east of Manhattan. This upscale community is known for its beautiful tree-lined streets, manicured lawns, and elegant architecture. It’s a great place for families, with excellent schools, parks, and recreational activities.

What kind of activities?

The village of Garden City is home to numerous boutique shops, restaurants, and cafes. The Garden City Hotel, which has hosted numerous dignitaries and celebrities over the years, is a popular spot for dining and drinks. Plus, the Cradle of Aviation Museum, located on the site of the former Mitchel Air Force Base, is a must-visit for aviation enthusiasts.

Port Washington

Port Washington is a vibrant waterfront community, also located in Nassau County, about 20 miles east of Manhattan. The town is known for its picturesque marinas, sandy beaches, and scenic hiking trails. It’s, again, a great place for families, with top-notch schools, parks, and recreational activities. The town of Port Washington has a lively downtown area with numerous shops, restaurants, and cafes.

Love lazy afternoons?

The Port Washington Public Library, with its extensive collection of books, movies, and music, is a great place to spend an afternoon. And the Sands Point Preserve, a 216-acre estate with a mansion, gardens, and nature trails, is a popular spot for picnics and walks.


Huntington is a historic town located in Suffolk County, Long Island, about 30 miles east of Manhattan. The town is known for its rich history, beautiful beaches, and thriving arts scene. And with more quality schools, parks, and recreational options, it’s yet another ideal town for families.

The best spots?

The Paramount Theater, a historic venue that hosts concerts and shows, is a popular spot for entertainment. Also worth a regular look is the Heckscher Museum of Art, located in scenic Heckscher Park, which features an impressively extensive collection of American and European art. Plus, Huntington’s lively downtown area hosts numerous shops and eateries, making it a lovely town for spontaneous local get-togethers with friends.


Great Neck

Great Neck is an affluent village in Nassau County, about 20 miles east of Manhattan. The village is known for its beautiful homes, tree-lined streets, and excellent schools. It’s a great place for families and young professionals alike, boasting numerous potential activities and attractions.

Are you creative?

If so, the Great Neck Arts Center, which offers classes and workshops in various artistic disciplines, is a popular spot for creative types. Steppingstone Park, located on the waterfront, is a great place for picnics, boating, and fishing for the more outdoorsy people too.


Next, on my rundown of the Best Neighborhoods In Long Island, Roslyn is an old village about 20 miles east of Manhattan. It is also in Nassau County. The village is known for its magnificent homes, cool, tree-lined streets, and rich history. It’s a great place for retirees and families, too. 

With lots to do and see!

Gerry Park, a popular spot for outdoor concerts and events, is located in the heart of the village. Then the William Cullen Bryant Preserve, a large nature preserve with hiking trails and scenic views, is a great place for outdoor activities. Also, no trouble finding lovely little shops and cafes in the downtown area.


Northport is a picturesque village located in Suffolk County, Long Island, about 40 miles east of Manhattan, including its beautiful waterfront, historic homes, and thriving arts scene. The abundance of fun things to do and see makes it a fantastic location for families and the elderly.

But if you do have kids…

The Northport Historical Society operates several historic properties and offers both tours and educational programs. Northport Harbor, located on the waterfront, is a popular spot for picnics, boating, and fishing. And catching the rays in this area while strolling about is really a lovely experience.


Other Neighborhoods of Interest in Long Island

Rockville Centre

The St. Agnes Cathedral, a historic church with beautiful stained glass windows, is a popular spot for visitors to Rockville Centre. The village boasts many cute and interesting shops and places to eat, too. 

East Hampton

The town of East Hampton has a lively gallery scene. The Guild Hall, a cultural center that hosts art exhibitions, concerts, and events, is a very popular spot for both locals and visitors. The East Hampton Historical Society, which operates several historic places of interest, offers tours and educational programs for kids, too.

East Hampton


The hamlet of Jericho has a wonderful spot for book lovers, the Jericho Public Library. Featuring an extensive collection of books, movies, and music, it is a great place to relax, unwind and take in whatever literature and art floats your boat.


The Massapequa Preserve, a 432-acre park with hiking trails and ponds, is an excellent spot for outdoor activities. Then, John J. Burns Park, located nearby, offers sports fields, playgrounds, and picnic areas.

Tips for Choosing the Best Neighborhood in Long Island

Overall, most neighborhoods in Long Island are great places to call home. With its beautiful beaches, rich history, and bustling cities, it’s no wonder that so many people choose to live here. However, with so many options available, it can be challenging to know where to start. 

Here are some tips to help you find the perfect Long Island neighborhood for you.

Identifying the Best Neighborhoods In Long Island for Your Lifestyle

Determine Your Priorities

Before you start your search, determine your top priorities. What’s important to you in a neighborhood? Do you want to be close to shopping and restaurants? Is walking to school with your kids in the morning ideal? Knowing exactly what you’re looking for can help you narrow down your options and find the perfect haven for you and your loved ones.

Determine Your Priorities

Research the Schools

If you have children, one of your top priorities is likely to be the quality of the schools in the area. Long Island has some of the best schools in the country, but it’s important to research the specific schools in the neighborhoods you’re considering. Look at test scores, graduation rates, and other factors to determine if the schools meet your standards.

Consider the Commute

Long Island is a large area, and the commute to work can vary greatly, depending on where you live. So always consider the average commute time and transportation options when choosing your neighborhood. For example, if you work in Manhattan, living near a train station or major highway can save you a substantial about of time and hassle.

Look at the Crime Rates

Safety is a top concern for many people when choosing a neighborhood. So, always research the current crime rates in the neighborhoods you’re considering to ensure that you’re choosing a safe area. You can check crime statistics online or contact the local police department for information.

Check the Amenities

Do you want access to a pool or gym? Are there enough parks or recreational facilities nearby? And are there essential services in the area? Again, make a comprehensive list of the amenities that are important to you to ensure that the neighborhood you choose meets your needs.

Explore the Culture

As you can see, Long Island is a diverse area with a rich cultural scene. So, take the time to explore the different neighborhoods and get a feel for the local culture before committing to moving there permanently. Check out local festivals, museums, and art galleries in different seasons, too, if possible, to see what the area has to offer you year-round.

Cultural preferences…

If you’re looking for a diverse community, you may want to consider neighborhoods with a strong cultural presence. This is another thing that you’ll only really get a true reflection of by immersing yourself in it for a while. So have a little fun getting to know the locals!

Consider the Cost of Living

The cost of living can vary significantly from one Long Island neighborhood to another. So you’re going to need to take the time to fully research the cost of housing, utilities, and other expenses in the neighborhoods you’re considering. By doing this, you can choose a neighborhood that fits your budget and offers good value for your money.

Consider the Cost of Living

Talk to the Locals

As I just touched on, one of the best ways to get a feel for a neighborhood is to talk to the locals. So don’t be afraid to strike up a conversation with people you meet at the grocery store or coffee shop and ask them about the area. They may be able to offer insights into the community that you can’t find anywhere else.

Visit the Neighborhood at Different Times

To get a complete picture of a neighborhood, you need to visit at different times of the day, week, and even year. 


Then, drive through the neighborhood during rush hour to get a sense of traffic patterns. Visit on the weekend to see how busy the area is. Take a stroll through the neighborhood at night to get a sense of safety and security.

Check the Walkability

If you enjoy walking or prefer not to drive, consider the walkability of the neighborhood you’re considering. Look for sidewalks, crosswalks, and pedestrian-friendly streets. A neighborhood with a high walkability score can be remarkably convenient and promote a healthy lifestyle.

Look for Community Involvement

Any neighborhood with an active community can offer a sense of belonging and support. Look for neighborhoods with community centers, local events, and neighborhood watch programs. Also, check if the community has a website or social media page to see if they’re active and involved.

Consider the Climate

Long Island’s climate can vary depending on the neighborhood’s location. Coastal neighborhoods may have milder temperatures and more humidity, while inland neighborhoods may have colder winters and hotter summers. So consider the particular climate and how it may affect your physical comfort and lifestyle.

Evaluate the Noise Level

Noise can be a major issue, especially if you’re sensitive to it. You can check the noise level of the neighborhood by visiting at different times of the day and week. If you love the quiet life, look for neighborhoods away from busy roads, train tracks, or airports. Also, consider the distance from commercial areas or entertainment venues that may generate noise.

Factor in Your Lifestyle

Ultimately, the best neighborhood for you will depend on your lifestyle and preferences. If you’re an outdoorsy person, you’re going to want neighborhoods with hiking trails or parks nearby. If you’re a foodie, you’re going to favor neighborhoods with diverse cuisine options. So, carefully consider your personal interests and hobbies to ensure that you can take advantage of the lifestyle you want.

Consider Future Development

Finally, and probably most importantly of all, if you are permanently relocating to Long Island, is to consider the future development plans for the neighborhood. Are there any major construction projects planned that could affect the area’s quality of life? Are property values likely to rise or fall in the coming years? Make sure you have a good understanding of the area’s future before making any long-term commitments.

Frequently Asked Questions

How is the commute from Long Island to New York City?

The commute between Long Island and New York City will vary, depending on the neighborhood and mode of transportation. Generally, the Long Island Rail Road offers convenient access to the city from many neighborhoods. However, rush hour traffic can be heavy on Long Island’s highways, which can make the commute longer.

What are the crime rates like in Long Island’s best neighborhoods?

Fortunately, Long Island’s best neighborhoods tend to have lower crime rates than other areas. However, crime rates can still vary depending on the neighborhood. So, it’s always a good idea to research the crime rates of any neighborhood you’re considering.

Are there any environmental concerns to be aware of in Long Island’s best neighborhoods?

Some neighborhoods on Long Island may have environmental concerns related to air or water quality. It is also important to note that some neighborhoods in coastal areas can be more susceptible to flooding and storms due to their proximity to the ocean. Thus, you may need to properly research any potential environmental concerns before choosing your neighborhood.

Can I find affordable housing in Long Island’s best neighborhoods?

While some of Long Island’s best neighborhoods can be pricey, there are still many neighborhoods that offer affordable housing options. It’s advisable to work with a real estate agent who is familiar with the area to find the best options within your budget.

What types of restaurants and nightlife are available in Long Island’s best neighborhoods?

Long Island has a wide range of places to eat and things to do at night, from fine dining to casual restaurants and bars. Many of the best neighborhoods have their own local restaurant and nightlife scenes, while others are just a short drive away from popular dining and entertainment destinations.

What types of restaurants and nightlife are available in Long Island's best neighborhoods

What is the demographic makeup of Long Island’s best neighborhoods?

The makeup of Long Island’s neighborhoods varies, depending on the specific area. Some neighborhoods are known for their affluent residents and upscale lifestyles, while others have a more diverse mix of medium- and high-earning residents.

How easy is it to find parking in Long Island’s best neighborhoods?

Again, parking options can vary from neighborhood to neighborhood. But many of the best neighborhoods have ample parking options, including on-street parking and parking garages.

What types of public transportation are available in Long Island’s best neighborhoods?

Long Island’s public transportation system is primarily centered around the Long Island Rail Road. It provides service to many neighborhoods on Long Island as well as to New York City. Some neighborhoods also have local bus services or access to other transportation options, such as ferries.

What types of healthcare facilities are available in Long Island’s best neighborhoods?

Long Island is home to many top-rated healthcare facilities. This includes hospitals, clinics, and a variety of specialist medical centers. Plus, most of the best neighborhoods have easy access to these facilities.

Are You Planning on Relocating Soon?

If so, we have a ton of useful info to share with you! Depending on your priorities, interests, and budget, we can help you intelligently stack up any area in the US.

Does affluence inspire you?

Then check out the Richest Neighborhoods in America, the Richest Towns In New Jersey, and the Richest Cities in California in 2023!

Is safety your key concern?

No problem! Browse anywhere from the Safest Neighborhoods in Atlanta to the Safest Neighborhoods in Philadelphia, the Safest Cities in Texas, and the Safest Places to Live in Florida – simply search our site for your areas of interest. We can even answer, Can A Felon Move to Another State?

Will you be working in New York?

Then you may be considering forgetting the commute and simply moving there! Find out all about the Most Dangerous Neighborhoods in NYC, exactly How to Get a Work Permit in New York, the Best Sites to Find A Job in New York City, or even Why Are There No Walmarts in New York City?

Ok, back to today’s US neighborhood comparison

Final Thoughts

Long Island is a great place to call home, with numerous lovely neighborhoods that offer something for everyone.

In fact, whether you’re looking for a quiet suburban life or a bustling city environment, Long Island has it all.

By considering your priorities, researching the available options, and checking the amenities, it’s perfectly possible to find the best-fitting Long Island area for you and your family.

Enjoy exploring Long Island!

5/5 - (1 vote)

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

About Wendy Young

Wendy runs an employment agency with her husband, Ian, in Rochester, New York.

She loves nothing more than hosting a good dinner party and spends weeks intricately planning her next 'event.' She often uses these to introduce clients to potential employers in a relaxed, informal fashion. The food must be delicious, the cocktails and wine must be a perfect match, and the decor needs to impress without being over the top. With all that going on, it's amazing that she gets any time to write about her thoughts on securing the dream job.

They live on the outskirts of New York with their poodle, Princess.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

error: Content is protected !!
Scroll to Top